The Supreme Court on 17 February 2023 granted Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision on enforcing possession orders against "persons unknown" living in two Dublin properties.
The properties are 31 Richmond Avenue, Fairview, Dublin 3, and 21 Little Mary Street, Dublin 7. On 23 June 2008 the High Court granted an order for possession of both to a lender after the mortgagor defaulted. An appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed in 2014. The interest later passed to Pepper Finance, which was substituted as plaintiff on 18 November 2020.
Pepper Finance sought orders that the occupants surrender the properties. The High Court granted a mandatory interlocutory order against "persons unknown in occupation". It later made orders invoking its contempt jurisdiction over alleged non-compliance.
The occupants appealed. On 28 July 2022 Ms Justice Whelan, in the Court of Appeal, allowed the appeal. She found that a later order should have been served on all the appellants before the motion to attach and commit. She also found that the occupants should have been named as defendants, and that the penal endorsements were invalid.
The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Mr Justice Charleton and Mr Justice Hogan said the case raises important questions about how contempt of court is exercised. These include how orders are served, whether it is right to proceed against "persons unknown" when some are identifiable, and whether people who entered a property as trespassers can claim constitutional protection for their dwelling.
The respondents say the loans have since been sold by Pepper Finance, which could raise a question over its standing to appeal. The court will hold a case management meeting to refine the issues. Leave was granted.