The Supreme Court on 17 January 2023 granted Right to Know CLG leave to appeal in its case against the Commissioner for Environmental Information and Raheenleagh Power DAC.
Right to Know sought environmental information from Raheenleagh in 2019. Raheenleagh refused, saying it was not a public authority under the 2007 access to environmental information regulations. The Commissioner agreed with the company.
The High Court (Mr Justice Owens) reversed that decision on 25 January 2021. It held that Raheenleagh was a public authority, because it exercised special powers and was entrusted with services of public interest. It also held that the company was under the control of the ESB.
Raheenleagh appealed to the Court of Appeal, and the Commissioner did not. On 21 September 2022 the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court. It accepted that Raheenleagh had special powers. It held that the company was not entrusted with services of public interest and was not under the control of a public authority. It also declined to refer any question to the Court of Justice of the European Union.
Right to Know applied for leave to appeal. The Commissioner also applied, even though he had not taken part in the Court of Appeal. Both said a reference to the Court of Justice would be needed, but they did not agree on the questions. Raheenleagh opposed both applications.
The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice Dunne and Ms Justice Baker said the case met the constitutional threshold. It pointed to the divergence between the Commissioner, the High Court and the Court of Appeal, and said the proper construction of the regulations was a matter of general public importance.
Leave was granted to both Right to Know and the Commissioner. Raheenleagh was given leave to cross-appeal on whether it has special powers. The issues will be refined at case management.