localnews.ie

Jason and Dean Bradley refused Supreme Court appeal in Lucan murder case

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The brothers wanted the court to rule on a witness interviewing technique used by gardaí and on the warnings a trial judge should give a jury.

The Supreme Court on 10 February 2023 refused Jason Bradley and Dean Bradley leave to appeal in the case arising from the murder of Neil Reilly in Lucan.

The Bradleys had already lost an appeal in the Court of Appeal, which ruled on 10 March 2022. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed a further appeal.

The brothers wanted the Supreme Court to rule on a form of witness interview called enhanced cognitive interviewing. A witness gave her account in that way about seven months after the attack. The trial judge admitted her evidence. They also wanted the court to consider expanding the categories of evidence for which a trial judge should warn the jury.

The prosecution said an upset witness was simply revisited when she was less traumatised. It said a video recording was made, and the defence could scrutinise it.

The Court of Appeal had found that the trial judge was correct to admit the evidence and that no more specific warning to the jury was needed.

The Supreme Court panel of Mr Justice Charleton, Mr Justice Woulfe and Mr Justice Collins found nothing to justify a second appeal. It said the case raised no point of law of general public importance and did not engage the interests of justice. Leave was refused.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal