localnews.ie

Martin Morgan confiscation order case goes to Supreme Court on DPP appeal

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Director of Public Prosecutions is challenging a Court of Appeal ruling that the High Court could not issue a warrant for his arrest over an unpaid confiscation order.

The Supreme Court on 10 February 2023 granted the Director of Public Prosecutions leave to appeal in the case of Martin Morgan, who is the accused and respondent.

On 22 February 2008 Mr Morgan was convicted in the Dublin Circuit Court of running a brothel and organising prostitution. He was sentenced to three years in prison and fined €24,000. His appeal against conviction was dismissed.

Confiscation provisions then followed. The Circuit Court made a confiscation order, which was amended on appeal to €243,583. If unpaid, the order carries up to three years of additional imprisonment. Mr Morgan said he could not pay, and did not.

The prosecution then went to the High Court. On 18 November 2020 Mr Justice Coffey ordered Mr Morgan's arrest so that he could answer for non-compliance. Mr Morgan said the court had no power to issue such a warrant. The DPP said the criminal case had not ended, and that the High Court's inherent power and constitutional due process allow it to compel his attendance.

The Court of Appeal reversed the High Court on 23 June 2022. The DPP then applied to the Supreme Court. The panel of Mr Justice Charleton, Mr Justice Woulfe and Mr Justice Collins said the issues have wide implications and meet the requirements for a direct appeal.

The appeal will centre on five questions, subject to case management. They include when a criminal case ends where a confiscation order remains unsatisfied, whether the High Court has an inherent power to order an accused's arrest to answer in person, and whether the High Court could imprison an accused for up to three years in his absence.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal