localnews.ie

Michael O'Flynn granted Supreme Court appeal in personal insolvency arrangement case

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will decide whether a creditor who did not file a proof of debt can still object to a personal insolvency arrangement.

The Supreme Court on 7 February 2023 granted Michael O'Flynn leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a dispute over a personal insolvency arrangement.

The case concerns an arrangement for John O'Driscoll of Kilcrea, Owens, Co. Cork. Mr O'Flynn was included as a creditor in the protective certificate. The personal insolvency practitioner asked him to file a proof of debt under section 98(2) of the Personal Insolvency Act 2012. It is accepted that he did not. As a result he was not entitled to vote at the creditors' meeting or to share in any distribution under the arrangement.

The creditors' meeting approved the arrangement. Mr O'Flynn was served with a notice under section 112, which says a creditor may object, and he lodged a notice of objection. He objected on the ground in section 120(d), that the debtor did not meet the eligibility criteria because he was not insolvent. It was accepted that, once approved, the arrangement would bind him in respect of the debt.

The Circuit Court held that he was not entitled to object, because failing to file a proof of debt left him with no standing in the process. On appeal, the High Court (Mr Justice Owens) upheld that decision on 25 July 2022.

The Supreme Court panel of Chief Justice O'Donnell, Ms Justice Dunne and Ms Justice O'Malley said the case turns on how the 2012 Act is interpreted. It raises a matter of general public importance because the decision will affect other cases and bind the Circuit Court in future.

The court found exceptional grounds for a direct appeal. It noted that section 39 of the Courts of Justice Act 1936 normally prevents an appeal from the High Court to the Court of Appeal, and said definitive guidance on the Act and the procedure to follow is desirable.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal