localnews.ie

Simon Gordon drunk-in-charge case: DPP granted Supreme Court appeal

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The case, stated by a Cavan Circuit Court judge, asks whether a Circuit Court hearing a District Court appeal can convict of a different offence.

The Supreme Court has granted the Director of Public Prosecutions leave to appeal in the case of Simon Gordon, who was convicted in the District Court of being drunk in charge of a vehicle. The application was brought at the suit of Sergeant Cian P.M. O'Brien, and the determination is dated 28 November 2023.

The case began at a sitting of Cavan Circuit Criminal Court on 22 January 2020. Mr Gordon appeared before Judge Comerford to appeal his District Court conviction under section 5(4)(a) and (5) of the Road Traffic Act 2010.

At the end of the prosecution's evidence, a direction was applied for on his behalf. The judge found the evidence insufficient to convict Mr Gordon of the section 5(4) offence. He was of the clear view, however, that there was evidence of an attempt to drive while Mr Gordon was in charge of the vehicle. That suggested guilt of a different offence, under section 4(4), of which Mr Gordon had not been convicted in the District Court.

Section 5(6) says a person charged under section 5 may be found guilty of a section 4 offence instead. The judge had serious reservations about whether a court hearing an appeal could use that power at all. He stated a case on questions of law for the Court of Appeal.

The Court of Appeal, with Edwards J., McCarthy J. and Ní Raifeartaigh J., answered the first question in the affirmative. It was not satisfied that the section 5(6) power could be exercised by a Circuit Court judge hearing a District Court appeal. Its ruling was dated 28 July 2023.

The DPP told the Supreme Court that the ruling removes the Circuit Court's appellate power to convict of an alternative offence. She said other criminal statutes use alternative verdict provisions, so the issue has wider consequences. Mr Gordon said the provision applies only to a District Court trial.

O'Donnell C.J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. said the case involves a matter of general public importance on how section 5(6) is to be interpreted. They noted the issue may arise in other District Court appeals and that further clarity is in the public interest.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal