localnews.ie

Robert Hodgins drink-driving case: DPP granted Supreme Court appeal

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The case stated concerns whether a garda signing breath test statements in the wrong order invalidates the evidence, and the Supreme Court will revisit an earlier ruling.

The Supreme Court has granted the Director of Public Prosecutions leave to appeal in the drink-driving prosecution of Robert Hodgins, brought at the suit of Garda Robert O'Grady. The determination is dated 10 November 2023.

The appeal will test whether the Supreme Court should revisit an earlier decision on the signing of breath test statements. The court said that if the parties keep to the time limits set in case management, it can hear the appeal early without giving it priority. Mr Hodgins had asked for a priority hearing, because the case stated relates to an ongoing prosecution in the Circuit Court.

Mr Hodgins is charged with driving while the concentration of alcohol in his breath exceeded the statutory limit. The breath testing apparatus produced two identical statements of the result, and the law requires both the garda and the defendant to sign them. The garda did not sign in the correct sequential order. Mr Hodgins has always said this meant the statement was not "duly completed" under section 20 of the Road Traffic Act 2010.

He was convicted in the District Court and appealed to the Circuit Court. The Circuit Court judge considered himself bound by an earlier case, DPP v Lloyd Freeman. In that case the High Court held that a mistake in the sequence of signatures invalidated the evidential presumption otherwise applying to the statement.

The judge thought a later Supreme Court decision, DPP (McMahon) v Avadenei, might require him to assess the consequences of the breach instead. On a case stated, the Court of Appeal ruled on 7 July 2023 that it and the Circuit Court must follow Freeman.

The DPP asked the Supreme Court to revisit Freeman in light of Avadenei. Mr Hodgins said Avadenei did not overrule Freeman and that no matter of public importance arises.

O'Malley J., Baker J. and Woulfe J. said a perception of conflict or incongruity between two of the court's decisions can raise an issue of general public importance, and that it does here.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal