The Supreme Court has granted Gerry Gearty and Sean Beirne leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their challenge to the law used to create offences under the habitats regulations. The determination was delivered on 31 October 2023.
The two men were prosecuted over the refusal of entry to an authorised officer and the obstruction of an authorised officer, offences created by the European Communities (Birds and Natural Habitats) Regulations 2011. The District Court judge assigned to the Longford area is one of the respondents. The criminal proceedings were in effect stayed while the judicial review went ahead.
The applicants challenged the validity of section 3 of the European Communities Act 1972. They said it allows the Executive to create serious criminal offences, and so removes them from scrutiny by the Oireachtas. They described themselves as domestic turf cutters who exercise longstanding turbary rights and are members of the Turf Cutters and Contractors Association.
Simons J. dismissed their challenge in the High Court on 20 July 2023. He found the provision could be applied in line with the Constitution, because the Minister's discretion is narrow when an offence must be created to give effect to EU law.
The Director of Public Prosecutions, the Minister for Arts, Heritage and the Gaeltacht, Ireland and the Attorney General opposed the application. They also sought leave for a cross appeal.
Charleton J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. said the case raised a discrete legal issue of general public importance. They noted that Ireland is the subject of EU infringement proceedings, so it was in the public interest to resolve the matter quickly and an appeal to the Court of Appeal was unlikely to clarify it.
Leave was granted on one issue: whether a Minister may constitutionally create an indictable offence by regulations made under section 3. The court refused leave on the cross appeal. A case management hearing will be arranged.