localnews.ie

Paul Barlow and mussel fishers granted Supreme Court appeal over State management

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will hear only the negligence question, having found no uncertainty over the applicants' claims for breach of constitutional rights.

The Supreme Court has granted Paul Barlow and a group of mussel fishing businesses leave to appeal their claim for damages against the State over the management of mussel seed stocks. The determination was delivered on 31 October 2023.

The plaintiffs fish, harvest and sell ground or bottom mussels, and depend on an allocation of mussel seed. For about two decades they have blamed State mismanagement for the depletion of those stocks. They also objected to Northern Ireland registered vessels being allowed to fish for mussel seed in Irish territorial waters. The defendants are the Minister for Communications, Marine and Natural Resources, the Registrar General of Fishing Boats, Ireland and the Attorney General.

The proceedings began in 2006. The High Court dismissed all of the plaintiffs' claims, which included negligence, breach of constitutional rights and breach of legitimate expectation.

The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Edwards J with Collins and Power JJ agreeing, found that there had been mismanagement of the resource. It still held that the State owed the plaintiffs no duty of care in negligence, and that they had not shown a breach of constitutional rights or any need for a special remedy.

The plaintiffs told the Supreme Court that their case raised novel issues about the duty of care owed by public bodies. The State said all issues had been answered and no matter of general public importance arose.

Charleton J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. granted leave on the issue of liability in negligence. They said it was a matter of general public importance that uncertainty over the State's potential liability in managing a natural resource be "clarified to the greatest extent possible".

The court refused to go further on the constitutional claims. It said a claim for damages cannot be made where the common law offers an adequate remedy, and that lack of success does not make a remedy inadequate.

It asked counsel for the State to be ready at the first case management conference to clarify its position on pure economic loss. It also said the parties should address whether there was evidence of loss.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal