The Supreme Court has granted the board of management of Gaelscoil Moshíológ leave to appeal in its long-running unfair dismissal dispute with the school's principal, Aodhagán O'Suird. The determination, delivered on 31 October 2023, lets the board appeal directly from the High Court.
The board lost its High Court appeal against a Labour Court decision that Mr O'Suird had been unfairly dismissed. In a judgment on 14 July 2023, the High Court ordered that he be reengaged from the date of his dismissal. The board was also ordered to pay his costs on a legal practitioner and client basis.
The case has been through five hearings: a board disciplinary hearing, a disciplinary appeals panel, the Workplace Relations Commission, the Labour Court and the High Court. The only allegation pursued in the disciplinary proceedings was that the names of "eighteen non-existent children" were added to the school roll in or about September 2009. Mr O'Suird has always maintained that the board knew of and approved his conduct on enrolment figures. The High Court said the allegations of fraud were manifestly unfounded.
The board put forward nine grounds, including when a school can validly dismiss a principal over overstated enrolment figures and whether the High Court can vary a remedy on appeal. Mr O'Suird opposed leave. He said the case was a fact-specific, unexceptional employment dispute, that the repeated appeals had harmed his health, and that he is now back working in the school. He also said the board had been dissolved and had no standing to appeal.
Charleton, Murray and Donnelly JJ said matters of general public importance arise. They described them as matters that "could have implications for other disciplinary investigations and employment law proceedings". They said that, with no other appeal available, the constitutional threshold for an appeal from the High Court had been met.
The court was not satisfied that the High Court judge's remarks on the make-up of the Disciplinary Appeals Panel raised such a matter.
The appeal will cover how far the High Court can review the employer's conduct, the factors in dismissing a principal over enrolment returns, reengagement against reinstatement, and costs. Leave is provisional on the board's authority to bring the appeal being established. An early case management hearing will examine that.