localnews.ie

Kevin Tracey refused Supreme Court appeal over case-management order

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had upheld a High Court order limiting the time for remaining liability evidence in proceedings that date back to 2004 and earlier.

The Supreme Court has refused Kevin Tracey, trading as Engineering Design and Management, leave to appeal. The determination was delivered on 31 October 2023.

Mr Tracey is the plaintiff in High Court proceedings against Michael Burton, Anne (Áine) O'Connor as personal representative of the late Charles O'Connor, Burton and O'Connor Limited and FPQ Consulting Engineers. He claims a contract with the defendants was not honoured and caused him and his firm loss. The events go back to 2004 and earlier.

During the trial, Mr Justice McGrath made a case-management order. It gave each side two and a half days to finish outstanding evidence on liability. It also required any psychiatric report Mr Tracey wanted to rely on to be obtained within two months.

The Court of Appeal dismissed Mr Tracey's appeal against that order. He then asked the Supreme Court to hear a further appeal. He argued that his time had been unfairly cut and that he had been unfairly required to be psychiatrically examined and needed time to answer that evidence.

The respondents said the order was an ordinary use of High Court authority. They pointed to the expense, the death of a party and the ongoing nature of the proceedings.

Charleton J, Murray J and Donnelly J refused leave. They said a trial judge has wide discretion over the management of an ongoing case. The court found nothing in the application that met the constitutional criteria.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal