localnews.ie

Peadar Ó Baoill refused Supreme Court appeal in Gweebarra River fishing rights case

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court said the dispute over the Donegal fishery raised no issue of general public importance and no clear error by the Court of Appeal.

The Supreme Court has refused Peadar Ó Baoill, John Gerard Boyle and John Boyle permission to appeal in their long-running dispute with Inland Fisheries Ireland, in a determination dated 26 October 2023. The three defendants had asked the court to hear an appeal against a Court of Appeal ruling that went against them.

The proceedings began in June 2008 and concern fishing rights on a stretch of the Gweebarra River in Donegal. The fisheries agency, called the Inland Fisheries Board in the earlier judgments, sought an order restraining the defendants from interfering with its right to manage and regulate access to the fishery. The defendants counterclaimed, asserting rights of their own.

In the High Court, Ms Justice Laffoy found that the defendants had not established any entitlement to fish on the river. Ms Justice Pilkington later struck out the rest of their claim, and the Court of Appeal dismissed their appeal.

The applicants argued that the Court of Appeal had erred over the paper title of the agency's predecessor. The agency opposed leave.

Charleton J., Hogan J. and Donnelly J. extended time, because the application was made out of time and the delay was very short, but refused leave. The court said the dispute concerned contract and local custom and practice, and no legal issue of general public importance had been identified. It also found no clear error by the Court of Appeal that would justify leave in the interests of justice.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal