localnews.ie

Sharon Browne and David Egan refused Supreme Court appeal over Covid vaccine case

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court's costs order against them stands, after it dismissed their bid to halt the children's vaccine programme as an abuse of process.

Sharon Browne and David Egan have been refused leave to appeal directly to the Supreme Court in their case against Stephen Donnelly, Micheál Martin, Dr Tony Holohan and Paul Reid. The determination was delivered on 24 October 2023.

They had asked the High Court to halt the Covid-19 vaccine programme for children. Twomey J described their claims as "baseless" and "scandalous". He found they were made without evidence beyond hearsay, speculation, websites, blogs and YouTube videos. He held that the case was an abuse of process.

He awarded the entire costs to the defendants. That order stays in place after this refusal.

After judgment, Ms Browne and Mr Egan asked Twomey J to step aside from the case. He rejected that request. He noted that they had raised no concern about him hearing the case until the decision went against them.

In the Supreme Court they alleged breaches of informed consent and the precautionary principle, and of constitutional rights. They also said they were denied a fair hearing. The defendants said the appeal came from an unsuccessful interlocutory order and raised no matter of general public importance.

The Supreme Court said the legal principles Twomey J applied are longstanding. It found no basis to conclude that they were denied a fair hearing, or that the judge erred on costs or recusal. The panel was Charleton J, Murray J and Donnelly J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal