localnews.ie

Kirstie McGrath granted Supreme Court appeal over mandatory hotel quarantine charge

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear her direct appeal from the High Court, which upheld the Health Minister's power to designate countries for Covid-19 hotel quarantine.

Kirstie McGrath, who is charged with resisting being brought to a designated quarantine facility, was granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court on 20 October 2023. The appeal goes directly from the High Court. In March 2021 the Minister for Health designated the United Arab Emirates and 32 other countries as high risk for Covid-19. Ms McGrath travelled to the UAE after that designation and was required to quarantine in a designated hotel on her return.

She refused to go to the hotel and was arrested and charged under section 38B(7) of the Health (Amendment) Act 2021. After a night in jail she was released on bail and completed the mandatory quarantine. A designated appeals officer refused her request for a review of her confinement.

Ms McGrath then asked the High Court to quash the decisions and make declarations. She argued that the Minister's designation power breaches the separation of powers. She also argued that the appeals officer's review is an impermissible exercise of the judicial function. Bolger J refused her claims.

The criminal charge remains before the District Court. The Director of Public Prosecutions has confirmed that the prosecution will proceed unless she succeeds in these proceedings. The Director opposed leave. She relied on a sunset clause that limited quarantine to three months unless extended by the Oireachtas, and argued that the Court of Appeal was the normal route.

The Supreme Court held that issues of general public importance arise about delegating law-making power to the Minister. It listed four issues for the appeal. They concern Article 15.2 of the Constitution, the effect of the sunset clause, whether the appeals officer's review breaches Article 34.1, and whether Article 40.4 cures any defect or the emergency justifies the measures.

The court said the issues can be refined at case management. The panel was Charleton J, Murray J and Donnelly J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal