localnews.ie

Niamh Mulreany granted Supreme Court appeal over mandatory hotel quarantine law

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will hear her direct appeal over the Health Minister's power to designate countries such as the United Arab Emirates for Covid-19 hotel quarantine.

The Supreme Court has granted Niamh Mulreany leave to appeal directly from the High Court over mandatory hotel quarantine, in a determination delivered on 20 October 2023. In March 2021 the Minister for Health designated the United Arab Emirates, with 32 other countries, as a high-risk country for Covid-19.

Ms Mulreany travelled to the UAE after the designation and was required to quarantine in a designated hotel on her return. She refused to go to the hotel. She was arrested and charged with resisting being brought to a designated facility.

She was released on bail after a night in jail and later completed the mandatory quarantine. A review of her confinement by a designated appeals officer was refused.

In the High Court she challenged the Minister's power to designate countries, and the appeals officer's power of review. Bolger J refused her claims. Ms Mulreany remains charged before the District Court. The Director of Public Prosecutions has confirmed that the prosecution will proceed unless she succeeds in these proceedings.

The Director opposed leave. The Director said the regime had a sunset clause, and that the review issue involved established principles. The Supreme Court said issues of general public importance arise about the delegation of law-making power to the Minister for Health. It listed four issues for the appeal. They include whether the delegation breaches Article 15.2 of the Constitution and what effect the sunset clause has.

They also include whether the appeals officer's review is an impermissible exercise of the judicial function. The last is whether Article 40.4 cures any defect, or the emergency justifies the measures. These issues can be refined at case management. The panel was Charleton J, Murray J and Donnelly J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal