localnews.ie

Seaconview refused Supreme Court appeal over out-of-court sale of Liam Fahey property

By Orla Quinn

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had agreed with the High Court that a receiver's sale of commercial units needed court approval before a contract was made.

Seaconview Designated Activity Company has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in its case against Liam Fahey. The determination was delivered on 18 October 2023.

The case concerns a building of commercial shop units. The original mortgage was held by Ulster Bank, and demand was made for payment of over €4 million. Seaconview took over the mortgagee's interest in December 2017 and appointed a receiver.

The receiver sold the property by tender without going to the High Court first. Seaconview then asked the court to approve a sale outside the court process and to let it keep the proceeds.

The High Court (Simons J) refused. There was not enough evidence that the price was the best available, and the court safeguards had not been used. The Court of Appeal agreed. Both courts said an application should be made before a sale is agreed. The Supreme Court said:

"so rooted in its facts"

was the application that an appeal "would not be sufficiently focused on matters of general public importance." It said the court's checks on such sales protect the mortgagor and other encumbrancers. The panel was Baker J, Hogan J and Collins J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal