The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Dublin City Council in its dispute with Michelle Maher over a derelict sites levy. In a determination delivered on 17 October 2023, it granted the council leave to appeal from the High Court on Circuit.
Ms Maher asked the courts to declare that a statutory charge on land for a derelict site levy, with penalty interest, was overreached when a mortgagee sold the land under its statutory power of sale. She also asked for a declaration that she was not liable to pay the levy.
The levy for the 2008 financial year was not paid within two months. It became a charge on the land in January 2008 under section 24 of the Derelict Sites Act 1990. The charge was registered in the Registry of Deeds in May 2013. Ms Maher bought the premises in 2014, and the sale closed in September 2014. In June 2015 the council demanded payment, saying the charge still applied. She paid under protest.
The Circuit Court upheld the council's argument and dismissed her claim in July 2022. On appeal, the High Court on Circuit (Simons J) held that the charge could be overreached, and was on the facts. It ordered repayment of the money she had paid under protest, and her costs. Those orders are stayed pending this application.
The council argues that the result means the charge often cannot be collected. It says the issue matters to local authorities across the State and reduces the deterrent effect of the levy. Ms Maher opposed leave. She argued that the matter should have gone to the Court of Appeal by way of a case stated, and that legislation could fix the issue. The Supreme Court said that argument did not fully represent its decision in Pepper Finance Corporation v Cannon, which accepted its jurisdiction in such cases.
It held that the meaning of section 24 is a question of general public importance and statutory interpretation of potentially broad application. The test for leave from a High Court on Circuit appeal was met. Ms Maher also sought to cross-appeal on a point of estoppel. The court refused that. It said the facts found by the Circuit Court did not support it, and the High Court had not decided the point. The panel was Baker J, Hogan J and Collins J.