localnews.ie

Debra James refused Supreme Court appeal over struck-out claim about pension advice

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had struck out her claim in deceit and conspiracy against a barrister over advice on her entitlement to an old age pension.

Debra James has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her case against James Watters and Derek Shortall, in a determination delivered on 16 October 2023. Her application concerned the striking out of her claim against the second defendant, a barrister.

She claimed deceit and conspiracy over advice about her entitlement to an old age pension. She said he had deliberately misled her about a judicial review she was considering.

The Court of Appeal struck out the claim in a judgment by Butler J on appeal from the High Court. It held that her claims lacked a credible basis and were mostly illogical.

Ms James told the Supreme Court that the Court of Appeal departed from the law. She also said she was treated under different rules because she had no lawyer.

The respondent opposed leave and said the Court of Appeal had applied the law. The Supreme Court said she did not challenge the principles the Court of Appeal applied. Nor did she point to any legal error.

It said her claim that the courts below had invented a new justification was not supported by their judgments. Leave was refused. The panel was O'Malley J, Baker J and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal