The Supreme Court on 31 January 2023 refused Reginald Carroll leave to appeal directly from the High Court in his case against the Residential Tenancies Board.
Mr Carroll's tenancy of a property in Burtonport, Co. Donegal began on 1 March 2020. His landlord served a notice of termination citing six grounds, broadly related to alleged anti-social behaviour. A tribunal of the Residential Tenancies Board upheld two of the six grounds.
Mr Carroll appealed to the High Court on a point of law, setting out 24 grounds of appeal. Ms Justice Bolger dismissed the appeal on 31 May 2022. His application to the Supreme Court was one day out of time. The board opposed an extension of time and opposed leave.
The Supreme Court panel of Ms Justice Dunne, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Murray said his grounds were stated in the most generalised way. It found that no error of law had been identified in the High Court decision, and that the application amounted to a request to review the tribunal's findings.
The court described his allegations of bad faith and political interference as abusive and unsubstantiated. It found no point of general public importance and no basis in the interests of justice. Leave was refused, and the court did not need to decide on the extension of time.