The Supreme Court will hear John Conway's appeal against a High Court decision on planning guidelines, it said in a determination on 13 October 2023. Mr Conway challenges the constitutional validity of section 28(1C) of the Planning and Development Act 2000. That section lets the Minister issue guidelines containing specific planning policy requirements.
Planning authorities and An Bord Pleanála must follow those requirements. He also challenges two sets of ministerial guidelines, the Urban Development and Building Heights Guidelines and the Apartment Guidelines. The challenge arose from An Bord Pleanála's decision to grant permission to Silvermount Limited for 545 build-to-rent apartments on the Naas Road.
The development materially contravened the Dublin City Development Plan 2016-2022 and the Naas Road Local Area Plan 2013 on building height and unit mix. The Board's Inspector still recommended permission, relying on the guidelines. Mr Conway argues that section 28(1C) is an unauthorised delegation of law-making power to the Minister. He also argues that it interferes with the role of local government.
The High Court (Humphreys J) refused all his claims in a judgment on 18 April 2023. It found that the delegation was permissible. The State respondents did not oppose leave. An Bord Pleanála said it would not take part in the appeal. The Supreme Court said the validity of section 28(1C) is a matter of general public importance. It said only the Supreme Court can resolve the issue finally.
It found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal. A Court of Appeal hearing would be unlikely to change the issue and would risk a second appeal. Leave covers the validity of section 28(1C) and of the two sets of guidelines. The issues may be refined at case management.
All sides asked for a priority hearing. The Court said the appeal will be heard as soon as reasonably practicable. The panel was Baker J, Hogan J and Collins J.