localnews.ie

William Twomey granted Supreme Court appeal over Special Criminal Court robbery conviction

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will decide what the law requires of someone who claims to have withdrawn from a joint criminal enterprise, a point it said has no authoritative ruling.

The Supreme Court has granted William Twomey leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal. In a determination delivered on 9 October 2023, it said his case raises an issue of general public importance about the defence of withdrawal from, or abandonment of, a common criminal enterprise.

Mr Twomey was convicted by the Special Criminal Court on 30 September 2021 of assault causing harm, robbery and demanding with menaces. The charges relate to an incident on 2 December 2017. The victim was lured to a location in County Louth under a false pretext, then assaulted, robbed and threatened.

Mr Twomey is not said to have been at the scene. It is accepted that he took an active part in at least planning and helping to bring about the scenario. The trial court also found that he later accessed material on a phone taken from the victim. The Court of Appeal upheld the convictions in a judgment on 25 April 2023.

His defence was that he had abandoned the common design before 2 December 2017. He relied mainly on evidence that in November 2017 he told a garda that the proposed victim was in danger of something happening "possibly in Northern Ireland". The garda confirmed the conversation. Mr Twomey said he then rang a police number in Northern Ireland, and was told it was a matter for the gardaí. He did not contact the victim or warn him. Both courts found his actions inadequate for the defence.

Mr Twomey's single argument is that the Court of Appeal erred in upholding that analysis. He says the standard set expected too much of him and focused on the lack of success of his efforts. The question, he argues, is whether they were at least potentially undermining of the scheme, or capable of raising a reasonable doubt. He points out that this Court has not authoritatively decided the requirements of the defence.

He has served the sentence imposed by the Special Criminal Court and did not seek a priority hearing. The panel was O'Malley J, Baker J and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal