Declan Kehoe and Una Kehoe have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in their case against Promontoria (Aran) Limited and Ken Fennell. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 4 August 2023. It is the second of two applications the Kehoes brought on the same day.
This one concerned a refusal by the High Court (Allen J) to adjourn a hearing. The Kehoes had wanted time to submit further affidavits. They argued that their credibility had been challenged in written submissions, and that they needed the affidavits to protect their good name and reputation.
The Court of Appeal dismissed their appeal on 30 March 2023. It said an appeal court will entertain an appeal against a High Court case management decision only in limited circumstances. It also found the appeal moot, because the motion to dismiss had by then been heard.
The Supreme Court agreed. It said any proposed appeal had been "entirely overtaken by that event". It found that no injustice had been shown, because the attack on their credibility could have been dealt with in written or oral submissions at the hearing.
The court added that decisions on whether further affidavit evidence may be filed are case management matters. It found no matter of general public importance and no interests-of-justice basis for leave.
The panel was O'Malley J, Baker J and Hogan J.