Eugenie Houston has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in her case with Wendy Doyle, in a determination delivered on 2 August 2023. The High Court (Quinn J) had granted Ms Doyle an order for delivery of vacant possession of property owned by Ms Houston.
Ms Houston complained that Ms Doyle, a solicitor, had previously been an employee of the judge, who is a former solicitor. She said he should have recused himself.
The judge refused to step aside, and the Court of Appeal upheld him on 4 May 2023. Ms Houston said this raised issues of bias, and Ms Doyle opposed the application.
Ms Doyle was temporarily employed as a locum at William Fry Solicitors in 2009. Quinn J. was one of dozens of partners at the firm at that time. The Court of Appeal said he had applied the correct test, which asks whether a reasonable person would apprehend bias. It called the connection a technical one of historic nature.
The Supreme Court said Ms Houston had not lodged completed books as required, despite repeated contact from the court office. It nonetheless decided the application on its merits.
It found no point of law of general public importance, because the Court of Appeal applied well-established principles. The case had already had a full appeal, so a further appeal was not needed in the interests of justice. The panel was Dunne J, O'Malley J and Baker J.