localnews.ie

CWTC granted Supreme Court appeal over Clonliffe housing in Fionuala Sherwin case

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The developer of a build-to-rent scheme of almost 1,600 units at the former Dublin Diocesan Seminary won leave to appeal directly from the High Court.

The Supreme Court has granted CWTC Multi-Family ICAV leave to appeal directly from the High Court in a judicial review brought by Fionuala Sherwin against An Bord Pleanála. The determination was delivered on 31 July 2023. CWTC is the notice party in the case. An Bord Pleanála granted CWTC permission in November 2021 for a large-scale build-to-rent development of almost 1,600 units. The site is the former Dublin Diocesan Seminary at Holy Cross College, Clonliffe, Drumcondra, Dublin 3. It was made under the strategic housing development procedure. The college has a large number of protected structures.

Ms Sherwin began her judicial review in December 2021. In a reserved judgment on 27 January 2023 the High Court (Humphreys J) quashed the permission, on two grounds. First, the demolition works would or might involve protected structures, and the Board had not complied with section 57(10) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 or the Dublin City development plan. Second, the Board had not given adequate reasons for disagreeing with the council's Conservation Officer about the removal of almost 40% of the mature trees in the grounds.

CWTC then sought a certificate to appeal to the Court of Appeal, but the High Court refused it on 8 May 2023. CWTC therefore applied to the Supreme Court. The Board did not seek the certificate, but it now supports the application. It said the decision has far-reaching implications for developments affecting protected structures.

CWTC says the case raises questions about section 57(10), and whether it applies to demolition of any part of a protected structure. It notes that there are apparently 8,500 protected structures in the Dublin City Council area alone. It also says some 1,600 housing units cannot now proceed.

Ms Sherwin opposed leave. She noted that the 2016 Act provisions have expired and that the High Court itself refused to certify any point of exceptional public importance. The Supreme Court said the case raises issues of general public importance about section 57(10) and about how development plans are interpreted. It also said the interests of justice call for a single appeal to the Supreme Court, given the size of the project.

Leave is conditional on further argument and the questions may be refined at case management. CWTC must file written submissions by close of business on 4 September 2023. The Board and Ms Sherwin must reply by 28 September 2023. Case management is listed for 4 October 2023. The panel was O'Malley J, Baker J and Hogan J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal