Arnaud D. Gaultier has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his long-running case against the Revenue Commissioners and several State respondents. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 31 July 2023.
Mr Gaultier was the sole member of a company that traded in wine. He says the Revenue's seizure of a consignment of wine in 2006 put the company out of business. The company was struck off the register in 2012 for failing to make returns. He has since brought the claims himself.
The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeals on 27 April 2022 and awarded costs against him. The High Court had held that the claim against the Revenue was bound to fail, because any injury was done to the company and not to him as a shareholder.
Mr Gaultier argued that the Court of Appeal should have revisited its judgment. He alleged bias and said it had not addressed his central legal arguments.
The Supreme Court disagreed. It said the Court of Appeal's judgment was fully reasoned and dealt with each issue he raised. It said allegations of bias must be based on evidence, and not just on findings against a litigant.
Leave was refused because his application did not meet the constitutional criteria. The panel was O'Malley J, Hogan J and Murray J.