The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Crofton Buildings Management CLG and Stephanie Bourke in their case against An Bord Pleanála. In a determination delivered on 31 July 2023, it granted them leave to appeal directly from the High Court. Fitzwilliam Limited is the notice party.
An Bord Pleanála granted Fitzwilliam permission in April 2021 to demolish a two-storey building and build 102 build-to-rent apartments in two buildings. The site is the St Michael's Hospital car park on Crofton Road, Dun Laoghaire. The application was made under the strategic housing development procedure. The first applicant is the management company for an adjacent residential development. Ms Bourke owns one of its apartments, and both took part in the planning process as objectors.
The Board conceded that its decision had to be quashed, because it had failed to apply a provision of the 2016 Act in a way that materially contravened the building height rules in the Dun Laoghaire-Rathdown Development Plan 2016. The main question then became whether the decision should simply be quashed or sent back to the Board.
In a judgment delivered on 20 December 2022, the High Court (Holland J) held that the application should be remitted to the Board. He also held that the 2022 Development Plan should apply, and that the Board should hold an oral hearing. In a further judgment on 16 May 2023 he certified points of law and granted the applicants leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The applicants argue that the remittal conflicts with existing High Court case law and distorts the statutory scheme. Both the Board and Fitzwilliam dispute that, but they support the application for leave. The Board said the outcome would probably govern some ten other challenges to strategic housing development permissions. The Supreme Court said the case raises issues of general public importance on the scope of the power to remit, including the new section 50A(9A) of the 2000 Act. It said the High Court's directions on an oral hearing also raise important points of law. It found it in the interests of justice that there be a single appeal, directly to the Supreme Court.
Leave covers the points certified by the High Court and the ten grounds raised by the applicants. It is conditional on further argument, and the grounds may be refined at case management. The applicants must file written submissions by close of business on 4 September 2023. The Board and the developer must reply by 28 September 2023. Case management is listed for 4 October 2023. The panel was O'Malley J, Baker J and Hogan J.