Rafal Marian Niewiadomski has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against an order for his surrender to Poland. The Supreme Court delivered its determination on 27 July 2023, in a case brought by the Minister for Justice.
The Regional Court in Bydgoszcz seeks his surrender on a European Arrest Warrant issued on 15 November 2021. It concerns theft-type offences alleged to have been committed in 2004. Mr Niewiadomski has lived in Ireland since 2005 and has been the subject of several earlier warrants.
He argued that the delay in seeking his surrender amounted to an abuse of process. He said the Polish authorities had long known where he lived. He also argued that surrender would breach his right to family life. The High Court (Naidoo J) rejected both arguments on 8 May 2023 and ordered his surrender. The judge refused him leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
He then went to the Supreme Court, where he argued that systemic deficiencies between authorities should have been taken into account. His application was out of time, and he asked for an extension.
The Supreme Court said his issues came from applying well-established principles to the facts of his case. It said the court is no longer one for correcting errors in applying such principles. It added that this did not mean there had been an error. He had not met the constitutional threshold for a further appeal.
The panel was Dunne J, Baker J and Donnelly J.