localnews.ie

Mark Crawford granted Supreme Court appeal over murder conviction and self-defence law

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Supreme Court will decide how self-defence applies in murder cases where the accused used more force than was reasonably necessary in the circumstances.

The Supreme Court has granted Mark Crawford leave to appeal to it from the Court of Appeal in his murder case. The determination was delivered on 26 July 2023. Mr Crawford was convicted of murder by a unanimous jury verdict at the Central Criminal Court on 10 September 2020. On 2 October 2020 he received the mandatory sentence of life imprisonment. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal against conviction on 31 March 2023.

At his trial he raised self-defence. He had stabbed the victim six times while both were in a public house. The defence put emphasis on his perceived threat of an attack rather than an actual attack.

Before the speeches to the jury, a legal issue arose about the subjective and objective elements of self-defence. The Director of Public Prosecutions relied on the long-standing case of The People (AG) v Dwyer. Mr Crawford argued that self-defence is made out where the accused genuinely believed force was necessary, and the force was reasonable in the circumstances as he believed them to be. The trial judge and the Court of Appeal rejected that argument.

Mr Crawford applied for leave on 11 May 2023. He said Dwyer is unclear, and that the same test applies in non-fatal cases under the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997. The DPP opposed leave.

The Supreme Court did not accept that a later statute changing the law in one set of circumstances creates uncertainty in murder cases. It said, however, that there must be no doubt about the nature and extent of the defence of self-defence when it is raised against a charge of murder.

It said Dwyer may not have considered a situation where force could be seen as reasonable in the circumstances as the accused believed them. The court set two issues for the appeal. These are the basis on which the unlawfulness of a killing is assessed, and the circumstances to be taken into account when more force than was reasonably necessary is used. No priority order was needed. The panel was Dunne, Baker and Donnelly JJ.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal