The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Peter and Rose O'Reilly in their compensation dispute with the Electricity Supply Board. It also granted the ESB leave to cross-appeal. The determination was delivered on 26 July 2023 and allows both appeals to go directly from the High Court.
The O'Reillys own land in County Cavan. In 2011 they were served with two notices under the Electricity (Supply) Act 1927, by which the ESB sought to acquire two wayleaves compulsorily. These were for an above-ground electric line. They sought compensation of €172,400, including damages for injurious affection to their retained lands.
A property arbitrator, Paul Good, issued awards on 8 July 2019. The ESB challenged his calculation by judicial review. The High Court (Heslin J) gave a written judgment on 22 February 2023 and made its order on 28 April 2023. The O'Reillys applied for leave in May 2023. Their case is about whether compensation for injurious affection can be awarded when the law that lets the ESB acquire wayleaves does not include the older provision that allows it. They say the ruling could affect the level of compensation across many cases.
The ESB did not oppose leave and accepted that the issues are of general and exceptional public importance. Mr Good took a neutral position and did not take part. The ESB wants to cross-appeal the finding that the arbitrator exercised his discretion fairly. It also wants to challenge the finding that it was not prejudiced by a late amendment of the claim. The Supreme Court said the matters raised:
"meet the constitutional threshold of exceptionality and are of general public importance."
It said the parties disagree on some of the High Court's conclusions, and that can be taken up at case management. No formal order for priority is needed, because the appeal is likely to be heard in the relatively near future. The panel was Dunne J, Baker J and Donnelly J.