The Supreme Court on 12 January 2023 refused Paul Coyle leave to appeal in the winding-up of Decobake Limited, where he was a former director.
Mr Coyle applied after the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeals on 8 February 2022. He asked the Supreme Court to set aside the liquidation, remove the liquidator, Declan De Lacy, and order that documents be supplied to him. Mr De Lacy, Denis McHugh and Deirdre Murphy all opposed leave.
The court said the application was out of time but looked at it anyway. It said the matters Mr Coyle raised were tied to the specific facts of his case, so no point of general public importance arose.
The panel was Mr Justice Charleton, Ms Justice Baker and Mr Justice Hogan. They noted that Ms Justice Costello had earlier called the argument that a rates collector could not petition for a winding-up "completely unsustainable".
The court said Mr Coyle had ample chance to protect his property rights, to adduce evidence and to raise his dyslexia. It found no inequality of arms and no new point of EU law.
It concluded that an appeal was not necessary in the interests of justice, and refused leave.