localnews.ie

John Paul McGann, Tibor Neugebauer and Piotr Skoczylas refused Supreme Court appeal in Permanent TSB case

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

They wanted to challenge a Court of Appeal refusal of interim orders about the legal costs of Permanent TSB Group Holdings directors, whose defence was covered by insurance.

John Paul McGann, Tibor Neugebauer and Piotr Skoczylas have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in litigation over Permanent TSB Group Holdings plc. The decision was delivered on 29 July 2022 by MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Baker J.

The three were petitioners in proceedings under section 205 of the Companies Act 1963 arising from the reorganisation and recapitalisation of the company. In the High Court they sought interlocutory orders to stop eleven named respondents being represented at the company's expense, using its resources for their defence, or keeping money it had paid.

Laffoy J. refused those orders in a judgment of 22 October 2013. She had before her a letter of 3 May 2013 from the insurer, AIG, confirming full indemnity for the defence costs. On 27 April 2022, the Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal. The three applied to the Supreme Court on 16 May 2022.

They argued that the Court of Appeal had altered the law on directors' use of company resources and had created a "new paradigm" on costs. They also said the costs order breached EU law. The respondents opposed leave.

The Supreme Court said the orders were refused because an insurance policy meant no company resources were being used. It found the point fact specific, said the orders were interlocutory only and that the main case would remain to be decided, and held that the constitutional threshold was not met.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal