Edijs Krimelis has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court against a High Court order sending him to Latvia under a European arrest warrant. The determination was delivered on 26 July 2022 by Dunne J., O'Malley J. and Baker J. The warrant relates to one offence: giving other people information that enabled them to commit a violent robbery of an elderly pensioner.
Mr Krimelis told the High Court he feared he would not get proper treatment for his medical conditions in Latvia. He relied on reports from international bodies that highlighted problems in Latvian prisons, including healthcare, inter-prisoner violence, staffing and physical conditions.
The High Court judge sought assurances from Latvia, and the Latvian authorities guaranteed standards of space, hygiene, safety, food and medical facilities. She found no substantial grounds to believe he faced a real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment and dismissed his objections.
In his application Mr Krimelis said the Supreme Court should decide what weight can be given to generalised assurances, especially where epilepsy medication was concerned. The Minister for Justice and Equality opposed leave.
The Supreme Court said there is a large body of case law on prison conditions in arrest warrant cases, and that surrender can be refused only in exceptional circumstances on the basis of precise information.
It held that the High Court judge had applied that law and had properly found the assurances sufficient. The constitutional threshold for leave was not met.