localnews.ie

Antonio Casimiro Lopes refused Supreme Court appeal over judge recusal and costs

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The dispute over a property he claims through adverse possession has run through earlier proceedings, and the Court of Appeal had upheld the refusal to recuse the judge.

The Supreme Court refused Antonio Casimiro Lopes leave to appeal from the Court of Appeal on 28 January 2022, in his case against Paul Sinnott, Barry Lyons and Graham Kenny.

The court heard that the long-running proceedings seek possession of a property on the basis of adverse possession. The same property was at the centre of earlier proceedings between the parties.

In the later case, Mr Lopes sought non-party discovery from Reynolds J. and was unsuccessful. He then applied for her to step aside, alleging bias in how she managed his application. She refused, and the Court of Appeal upheld that decision.

Costs were ordered against Mr Lopes at a hearing on 7 October 2021. His complaints to the Supreme Court mostly concerned the earlier proceedings and an argument that orders had been obtained by fraud.

The Supreme Court had a transcript of the High Court hearing. It said the hearing was conducted with care and that he had every opportunity to make his points.

It found nothing to suggest the Court of Appeal erred on objective bias and recusal. Mr Lopes had not met the constitutional threshold for an appeal.

The judges were MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Woulfe J.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal