localnews.ie

Mark Smith granted Supreme Court appeal in solicitors' negligence case over Leitrim house purchase

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will decide when a negligence claim against a solicitor in a house purchase begins to run for limitation purposes, after the Court of Appeal ruled it statute barred.

Mark Smith has been given leave to appeal to the Supreme Court in his negligence claim against the solicitors who acted for him and his then wife when they bought a newly built house in Gubadorish, Drumlish, County Leitrim. The determination was delivered on 13 July 2022 by a panel of Charleton, Woulfe and Murray.

The house was bought in 2006 for €240,000, financed by a mortgage with Start Mortgages. An engineer retained by the vendors had certified that it was built in substantial compliance with its planning permission. In 2008 the couple agreed to sell it for €280,000, but the buyer withdrew in October 2008 when it emerged that the house had not been built in line with the permission.

Mr Smith says the solicitors were negligent in failing to ensure he got good marketable title. The solicitors deny negligence. He issued proceedings on 26 May 2014, and a preliminary issue was fixed on whether his claim was statute barred.

The High Court held that it was not. It drew a distinction between a defect and the damage it later causes, and found that damage did not occur until the sale contract was rescinded on 16 October 2008. The Court of Appeal disagreed and held that the cause of action was complete when the purchase closed in July 2006, so time had started running then.

The Supreme Court said it had recently dealt with when negligence claims accrue in two other cases, one on building defects and one on financial loss, but neither concerned a claim against a solicitor over a conveyancing transaction. It held that the point at which time runs in such a case is of general public importance, and that it is in the interests of justice to grant leave given the effect of the Court of Appeal decision on Mr Smith's claim.

The appeal appears to raise a single issue: whether the Court of Appeal was wrong to find the claim statute barred, and in particular whether the claims arose when the purchase was completed in July 2006. Granting leave does not decide that question.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal