localnews.ie

Rosie Blackmore refused Supreme Court appeal over well charging order sought by Ken Byrne

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The High Court upheld the order on a judgment mortgage, and ruled her complaints about the solicitor were not relevant to the narrow question it had to decide.

The Supreme Court has refused Rosie Blackmore leave to appeal directly from the High Court in her case with Ken Byrne. The determination was delivered on 5 July 2022.

Mr Byrne is a solicitor who was involved in a probate matter about the will of Ms Blackmore's father. The case concerns two orders made by Murphy J. on 5 March 2012. A well charging order was made on foot of a judgment mortgage. Proceedings on it were brought in 2018.

The Circuit Court found against Ms Blackmore. Simons J. upheld that in the High Court on 21 February 2022. He said the only issue was whether the judgment mortgage had been correctly registered. He found the proofs were made out. He said her complaints about Mr Byrne were not relevant.

Ms Blackmore asked the Supreme Court to set aside the orders. Her grounds focused mainly on allegations of malpractice. The Supreme Court said she had been given the chance to put forward evidence in both courts. It found no due process rights were infringed.

It said it is bound by a trial judge's findings of fact. There was no significant new evidence. No issue of general public importance arose.

Charleton J., Woulfe J. and Murray J. refused leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal