localnews.ie

Ben and Sarah Jane Gilroy refused Supreme Court appeal in Start Mortgages possession case

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple wanted to challenge a High Court ruling that backed a possession order against their property, after fraud claims involving their former solicitor were rejected.

The Supreme Court has refused Ben and Sarah Jane Gilroy leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their case with Start Mortgages DAC. The determination was delivered on 5 July 2022.

The case concerns the registration of a mortgage against property owned by the couple. The Circuit Court made an order for possession. On 20 October 2021, O'Regan J. affirmed it in the High Court. She found they had not produced enough evidence to send the case to a full hearing.

The Gilroys alleged fraud between their then solicitor and Start Mortgages over changes to the initial lodging in the land registry on 12 January 2007. The Circuit Court judge found no evidence of this. The High Court judge found no proof of fraud or deceit.

The couple also asked for a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union. They claimed breaches of their rights under the EU Charter and the European Convention on Human Rights.

Start Mortgages said the case applied settled principles and was of personal importance only.

The Supreme Court said it is bound by a trial judge's findings of fact if credible evidence supports them. It said the law on sending cases to a full hearing is long established. It found no matter of general public importance and no interests-of-justice ground.

Charleton J., Woulfe J. and Murray J. declined leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal