The Supreme Court has granted Gideon Odum and his three children leave to appeal directly from the High Court in their case against the Minister for Justice. The determination was delivered on 29 June 2022.
Mr Odum is a Nigerian national who entered the State in 2007. A deportation order was made against him after his request to remain was refused. He says he is the father of the three children and is a joint guardian under a consent order made by the District Court in 2015. The applicants brought judicial review proceedings, arguing the Minister had not considered their constitutional rights.
A deportation order can have a very significant impact on the person it affects. The Supreme Court said it is in the interests of justice that the correct approach to constitutional family rights in deportation decisions be clarified.
The High Court agreed that constitutional rights were in issue. On 22 November 2021, however, the judge held that a breach would arise only if there was a "meaningful involved relationship" between Mr Odum and the children. The judge also held that the Minister did not need to set out constitutional considerations, since the underlying facts had been assessed. The judge refused a certificate for leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal on 2 February 2022.
The Minister opposed leave. She said the High Court applied well-settled law and the questions were premature.
The Supreme Court said the application met the constitutional threshold. It identified two issues of general public importance. One is whether the Minister must expressly consider constitutional family rights in a deportation decision. The other is how those rights are affected by the absence of a meaningful involved relationship, and whether that is the correct test.
The applicants had asked for priority because the proceedings are over five years old. The court said a formal priority order was not needed. It expects the appeal can be heard in the normal course without significant delay.
MacMenamin J., O'Malley J. and Woulfe J. made the decision.