The Supreme Court refused Sidney Sutton leave to appeal a Court of Appeal order for a retrial on 21 January 2022. The court said the decision to order a retrial was a matter within the discretion of the Court of Appeal.
Mr Sutton was convicted in the Circuit Criminal Court of five assaults and of producing an article capable of inflicting serious injury. The offences related to his then partner and happened at their family home on or about 6 February 2016.
He received four months for the four lesser assaults. He got two years, with the final year suspended, for the more serious assault and the production offence. The sentences ran concurrently.
The Court of Appeal found that prosecution editing of his garda interview memoranda was wrong, because the excluded material went to the core of his defence. It quashed the convictions and ordered a retrial.
Mr Sutton argued that a retrial should not happen because of alleged prosecutorial misconduct. The Supreme Court noted that the Court of Appeal had refused to let him amend his grounds to include those allegations.
It said the proposed appeal related to the particular facts of the case, and that "no matter of general public importance arises".
His application was filed late. The court extended time because he was acting for himself. The judges were O'Donnell C.J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J.