localnews.ie

Ray O'Sullivan consultant suspension case goes to Supreme Court on HSE appeal

By Ruairí Dolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Health Service Executive will challenge a Court of Appeal ruling that overturned the suspension of the Kilkenny consultant gynaecologist on administrative leave.

The Supreme Court has granted the Health Service Executive leave to appeal in its case with Ray O'Sullivan, a consultant gynaecologist at Saint Luke's Hospital, Kilkenny. The determination was delivered on 27 June 2022.

The court said the case concerns research Mr O'Sullivan carried out in 2019 during operations on women. It had not been approved by the hospital's ethics committee and did not have patient consent. It involved inserting a tube and inflatable balloon. Nursing staff raised concerns, and the women were contacted and told of apparent risks. They issued High Court proceedings individually.

Mr O'Sullivan was placed on mandatory paid leave from 6 August 2019. On 21 January 2020 the HSE decided to start disciplinary proceedings alleging serious misconduct, which could lead to dismissal.

Barr J. dismissed his judicial review of those decisions in the High Court. The Court of Appeal overturned the decision on suspension on administrative leave on 25 March 2022, because there was no evidence of a risk to patients. It did not interfere with the other decisions, so the disciplinary process continues.

The HSE wants to test the correctness of its procedures and protect the suspension decision. Mr O'Sullivan opposed leave. He said almost three years had passed and his ability to practise had been compromised.

The Supreme Court said the issues are likely to recur and have wider import for contracts that allow suspension. It identified two questions, which may be refined at case management. The first is how a court should approach a challenge to a contractual suspension power exercised where an employer considers that a person poses "an immediate and serious risk to the safety, health and welfare of patients or staff". The second is what procedures suspension requires.

O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Woulfe J. made the decision.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal