The Supreme Court has granted Danas Kairys leave to appeal directly from the High Court in his case with the Minister for Justice and Equality. The determination was delivered on 14 June 2022. Charleton J., O'Malley J. and Murray J. made the decision.
Lithuania seeks Mr Kairys's surrender under a European arrest warrant, so that he can serve a prison term imposed by a Lithuanian court. On 31 January 2022 the High Court (Burns J.) rejected each of his objections to being surrendered.
Mr Kairys sought leave on one issue only. He is a Lithuanian national, and there is no legal mechanism in Ireland by which he could ask to serve his sentence here. He wanted the court to consider the legal effect of that absence.
The Supreme Court noted that Ireland is currently in breach of its obligation to implement an EU framework decision on recognising custodial sentences from other member states. The Court of Justice of the European Union found this in Commission v Ireland on 24 March 2022.
In rejecting the argument, the High Court relied on two statements. One was that an earlier High Court decision had rejected a submission that the State must implement the decision. The other was that the Court of Justice had confirmed one of its provisions to be optional. The Supreme Court said both statements were erroneous. It said the errors seem to have come from submissions mistakenly put forward by the Minister.
The court said the error may have prevented the High Court from fully considering the issue and could cause confusion in other cases. Leave covers one question: whether the State's failure to enact the legislation gives any entitlement to resist execution of a European arrest warrant.