The Supreme Court has granted Stephen Duffy leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision on his sentence for assault causing serious harm. The determination was delivered on 2 June 2022.
The offence happened in the early hours of 29 August 2016 near old Tallaght village. Mr Duffy struck one blow to another man, who fell unconscious and suffered a serious brain injury. Mr Duffy returned after walking away and put him in the recovery position.
He pleaded guilty in April 2021. In July 2021 he was sentenced at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to four years, fully suspended. The conditions were that he pay a further €10,000 to the injured man within two years, and keep the peace for four years. A first sum of €5,000 had already been paid.
The Director of Public Prosecutions then sought a review for undue leniency. On 8 March 2022 the Court of Appeal quashed the sentence. It imposed four years with the last three suspended, on the same terms.
The Court of Appeal said the victim's views on imprisonment are relevant only to a very limited extent. It also said the victim's acceptance of money could not count as mitigation.
Mr Duffy argued that both findings raise matters of general public importance. The DPP said victims' views and compensation are already taken into account, but are not dominant factors.
The Supreme Court agreed that there are two matters of general public importance. It said they may arise in other sentencing hearings. Leave is granted on both, and they may be refined at case management.
MacMenamin J., O'Malley J. and Woulfe J. made the decision.