The Supreme Court has granted Tomás Heneghan leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The determination was delivered on 1 June 2022 by O'Donnell C.J., MacMenamin J. and Murray J.
Mr Heneghan is a graduate of the University of Limerick. He challenged parts of the Seanad electoral laws of 1937. He said he is entitled to vote in elections to Seanad panels. He also argued the laws breach the European Convention on Human Rights.
He has limited his appeal to the university seats. The 1937 Act on university members restricts those electors to graduates of the University of Dublin and the National University of Ireland.
The High Court rejected his claims on 17 November 2021. O'Moore J. gave the judgment. The court held that the Constitution lets the Oireachtas widen the university electorate. It does not require it to. The Constitution itself names the two universities. That could not be unconstitutional.
His application was filed out of time. He cited the Christmas break and his solicitors' focus on the Court of Appeal deadline. The respondents did not object, so the court extended time.
The respondents did not formally oppose leave. They said the case could in principle merit a direct appeal.
The Supreme Court said the case raises novel constitutional questions of significance. These include equality in elections, the separation of powers and how the Constitution should be read. They also include the role of expert evidence on constitutional history. The court said the appeal may be broad to allow full analysis.
A case management hearing will be held early. The court expects an early hearing in the normal course.