The Supreme Court has granted Protect East Meath Limited leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The determination was delivered on 30 May 2022. O'Malley J., Woulfe J. and Murray J. made the decision.
The company is challenging a decision of An Bord Pleanála. It asked the High Court for a protective costs order. Humphreys J. ruled on that application on 14 January 2022, in a judgment that also covered the Enniskerry Alliance case.
The ruling dealt with four special costs regimes. These are section 50B of the Planning and Development Act 2000, the Environment (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2011, and two versions of the "not prohibitively expensive" principle, under EU rules and the Aarhus Convention.
The judge held that one disputed ground was covered by section 50B and another by the 2011 Act. He adjourned a final ruling on the other grounds. He proposed that six questions should in principle be referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union. The Board has asked him to stay that reference until the Supreme Court decides.
The Supreme Court accepted that the application raises questions of law of general public importance and meets the constitutional criteria, including those for a direct appeal. The parties' notices raised the same issues as in Enniskerry Alliance. The Board suggested leave might not be needed in both cases.
The court granted leave. It reserved its decision on how far the appeal can progress given the proposed EU reference. It asked the parties to state their positions before the first case management hearing, which will also cover the Heather Hill and Enniskerry Alliance appeals.