The Supreme Court has granted Heather Hill Management Company CLG and Gabriel McGoldrick leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision on a protective costs order. The determination was delivered on 30 May 2022 in their case against An Bord Pleanála.
The applicants had challenged a Board decision by judicial review and sought a protective costs order. The Board accepted that section 50B of the Planning and Development Act 2000 covered some of their grounds but disputed others. The High Court gave the order for the proceedings in their entirety, even though not every ground concerned environmental issues.
The Board appealed. In the meantime the High Court ruled in the applicants' favour on the main case and awarded them costs. The Board still pursued its appeal on the costs order and gave the applicants a costs indemnity for that purpose.
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal, in a judgment of 14 October 2021. It held that the trial judge had wrongly interpreted section 50B and the reach of Article 9 of the Aarhus Convention. It described the disputed grounds as classic grounds of judicial review under national administrative law.
The applicants said that the ruling has caused confusion and restricts access to justice. The Board noted that they have no concrete interest in appealing. It did not oppose leave, since it accepts the issues should be decided by the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court said the application raises issues of general public importance that are significant to parties litigating in this area. It granted leave despite an element of mootness.
The appeal will be listed with two others, Enniskerry Alliance and Protect East Meath, for case management by a panel of the court.