The Supreme Court has granted John Colm Murphy leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his case with the Law Society of Ireland. The determination was delivered on 30 May 2022.
The appeal concerns a finding made against Mr Murphy by the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal on 28 September 1999. He was censured and ordered to pay the Society's costs. Mr Murphy practised as a solicitor in Co. Kerry in the mid-1990s. The finding was that he failed to file an accountant's report on the accounts of a practice he took over. His case is that the report covered months before he took the practice over.
Mr Murphy did not appeal at the time. He was struck off the Roll of Solicitors in 2009, and the 1999 finding was relied on by the Society in that application.
In 2020 he asked the High Court to extend time to appeal the 1999 finding. He said the Society had not disclosed a letter of 9 December 1997 indicating that the previous owner was responsible for those accounts. MacGrath J. refused. Noonan J. dismissed his appeal in the Court of Appeal on 9 December 2021. He accepted that the finding was "factually and technically incorrect" but was not satisfied it had caused an injustice.
The Supreme Court said the case was very old. It said it raises general issues about extending time to appeal decisions of professional disciplinary bodies. These arise where it is said that a regulator failed to disclose relevant material that bears on the correctness of the finding.
The court said refusing leave could leave an unsustainable finding and sanction impossible to correct. It said the public has an interest in the proper governance of the solicitors' profession. The court made no comment on the strength of Mr Murphy's material.
O'Donnell C.J., Baker J. and Hogan J. granted leave. The grounds can be refined at case management.