The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Justice and Equality leave to appeal in a case taken by Jaimee Middelkamp. The determination was delivered on 16 May 2022.
Ms Middelkamp is a Canadian citizen. She was given a Working Holiday Authorisation, with permission to stay from August 2018. The permission was extended to September 2021 during the Covid-19 pandemic. She applied in December 2019 to vary her permission. She was in Ireland to be with her husband, a Canadian student at UCC.
The Minister refused her application in January 2020. The High Court judge, Barrett J., found the reasons were inadequate. He also found the Minister had not considered her Article 8 rights under the European Convention on Human Rights. He gave judgment in July 2021. He then refused the Minister leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The Minister applied to the Supreme Court. She argued that a person with a finite permission, who has undertaken to leave, is not entitled to an Article 8 assessment. Ms Middelkamp opposed leave. She said her husband was due to finish his studies in summer 2022, when they planned to leave Ireland.
The court said the case raised an issue of general public importance. That issue is the reach of its earlier decision in Luximon. It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal.
The court will require both sides to address the Constitution. Leave is conditional on the Minister's undertaking that she will not seek costs against Ms Middelkamp, or reverse the High Court costs order in her favour, even if the appeal succeeds.