The Supreme Court has granted Jonathan Dowdall and Gerard Hutch leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The determination was delivered on 11 May 2022 by Charleton J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J.
The two men were charged with the murder of David Byrne at the Regency Hotel, Swords Road, Whitehall, Dublin 9, on 9 February 2016. The Director of Public Prosecutions certified that the ordinary courts were inadequate for their trials. Their trial before the Special Criminal Court was set for 3 October 2022.
Both challenged the continued existence of the Special Criminal Court in the High Court. They argued that section 35(2) of the Offences Against the State Act 1939 allows a proclamation only for a temporary period. The current court was set up under a proclamation in 1972, so, they said, it is no longer lawful. They also said the Government and the Dáil must keep the need for the court under review, and had not done so.
The State respondents said the Act sets no time limit. They said the review issue was a matter for the executive and not for the courts.
Barr J. rejected the applicants' case on 11 February 2022. He found no time limit in the Act. He held that the decision to keep the proclamation in place was a political question. He added that, even if wrong, the evidence showed a continuing review.
The Supreme Court said exceptional circumstances justified a direct appeal. It has not yet decided how the 1939 Act should be read or whether the present Special Criminal Court is outside it. Those issues matter to the public at large and are likely to affect others tried before that court.
The court also noted that the Court of Appeal was unlikely to narrow the issues and that the matter was time-sensitive.