localnews.ie

John McHugh refused Supreme Court appeal over Laois quarry registration decision

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

His judicial review of a Laois County Council letter from 2006 was brought almost fifteen years later, and the High Court and Court of Appeal both rejected it.

The Supreme Court has refused John McHugh leave to appeal in his case against Laois County Council. The determination was delivered on 10 May 2022. It concerns a quarry he owns at Parkahoughill, Ballylinan, County Laois.

Mr McHugh applied to register the quarry with the council in February 2005. On 3 January 2006 the council wrote to him, saying it did not intend to impose conditions because the quarry did not appear to have operated continuously since before 1964. He does not appear to have replied with submissions. He brought judicial review proceedings on 9 November 2020, almost fifteen years later.

Simons J. refused leave in the High Court on grounds of delay. He said the case was more than fourteen years out of time and that no good reason had been given for extending the period. The Court of Appeal agreed on 18 November 2021. It said the council's letter was not a decision that could be judicially reviewed.

Mr McHugh argued that an appeal was needed in the interests of justice, because, he said, his quarry had been closed for fourteen years.

The Supreme Court said the case applied well-established principles on time limits and the form of constitutional challenges. He had already had a full hearing and a full appeal. MacMenamin J., Dunne J. and Woulfe J. refused leave.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal