The Supreme Court has granted Save Cork City Community Association CLG leave to appeal directly from the High Court on one issue. The determination was delivered on 5 May 2022. Dunne J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. made the decision.
The association is challenging a decision by An Bord Pleanála to grant Cork City Council permission for flood defence works at Morrison's Island in Cork. The council applied directly to the Board under section 177AE of the Planning and Development Act 2000 on 31 July 2017, because the project needed appropriate assessment.
In the High Court, Humphreys J. delivered judgment on 28 July 2021. He dismissed the application as to certain reliefs, granted one declaration and adjourned one relief against the State respondents with liberty to re-enter. On 16 November 2021 he refused it leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.
The association raised two points. The first was whether the Board has jurisdiction to carry out environmental impact assessment screening under section 177AE, which does not expressly provide for it. Humphreys J. held that the power arises by necessary implication. The second was whether he applied the wrong test to "project splitting", given that the Morrison's Island works were part of a broader flood scheme for Cork City.
The Board argued that neither point was of general public importance.
The Supreme Court found a matter of general public importance on the first point. It said the issue may arise in other cases and that it is in the public interest to obtain further clarity. It did not accept that the second point met the threshold, because the High Court had relied on established principles and the arguments were fact-specific.
The court said exceptional circumstances justified a direct appeal. These included the refusal of leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal and the chance of greater legal certainty. The grounds may be refined at case management.