The Supreme Court has declined to grant Aidan Burns leave to appeal against a High Court order for possession of a property in County Waterford. The determination was delivered on 4 May 2022 in his case with Start Mortgages DAC.
The Circuit Court had refused Start Mortgages an order for possession of a family home on 12 June 2018. Owens J. reversed that on appeal in the High Court on 29 June 2020. He ordered the property to be delivered up, with the order stayed for six months.
Mr Burns applied for leave on 5 August 2020, which was out of time. He said he believed the time limit was longer. The court did not decide that point because it had enough papers to decide the application. It refused to extend time, saying this would not assist.
He argued that Owens J. used the wrong test for deciding whether a case should be heard summarily. He also raised interest calculations and the lack of a full hearing. Start Mortgages said the grounds had been fully dealt with in the High Court.
The Supreme Court said this was a straightforward application to enforce a mortgage. The High Court had applied well-established principles, so no point of general public importance arose. O'Donnell C.J., Charleton J. and Hogan J. gave the decision.